Wisconsin’s criminal jury instruction 140 describes the prosecutor’s burden of proof as “beyond a reasonable doubt.” However, it then contradicts itself by telling the jury “not to search for doubt” but instead “to search for the truth.”

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Michael D. Cicchini Michael Griesbach

Wisconsin prosecutor Michael Griesbach recently wrote, “To be sure, mistakes were made in the Avery case.”

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Making a Murderer Michael D. Cicchini Michael Griesbach Steven Avery

Whenever I write a motion or a brief on behalf of a client, it inevitably requires that I quote language from a published case, the criminal complaint, or some other document.

Tagged with: Brendan Dassey Critic's Corner ken kratz Michael Cicchini

When confronted by the police, innocent suspects often want to talk in order to clear up things on the spot. But in many cases, the police will only hear what they want to hear, and will spin an innocent person’s denial into evidence of guilt.

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Michael D. Cicchini Steven Avery

Steven Avery was convicted of murder in 2007. At his trial, the state called numerous scientific experts to help seal his fate. Then, a few years later, Wisconsin adopted the stricter Daubert standard for the admissibility of expert testimony. Had this supposedly tougher standard been in effect earlier, how would it have affected Avery’s trial?

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Michael D. Cicchini Steven Avery

Many law schools have let their students down over the past decade.

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Law school Michael D. Cicchini

Wisconsin courts have a long history of acting as a “superlegislature” and ignoring — and even contradicting — the Legislature’s words when doing so benefits the state.

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Michael Cicchini State v. Williams

The trouble with torture as an interrogation tactic is that the suspect will say whatever the interrogator wants to hear — regardless of whether it’s true. Unfortunately, this problem also plagues today’s softer, more sophisticated interrogation tactics.

Tagged with: Brendan Dassey Critic's Corner Michael Cicchini Steven Avery

In two previous columns I’ve discussed my rule 1.9 petition (written with my fellow attorney Terry Rose and supported by the attorneys Rob and Ellen Henak), in which I asked the Wisconsin Supreme Court to amend ethics rule 1.9.

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Michael D. Cicchini OLR State Bar Wisconsin Supreme Court

In my column from March, I wrote about Wisconsin’s criminal jury instruction 140. This instruction explains the notion of reasonable doubt, but then, strangely, concludes by telling jurors “not to search for doubt” when rendering their verdict but instead “to search for the truth.”

Tagged with: Critic's Corner juries Michael D. Cicchini

The wildly popular Netflix documentary “Making a Murderer” chronicles the two convictions of Steven Avery. The bulk of the documentary concentrated on Avery’s second case — his trial for the murder of Teresa Halbach — in which there was a great deal of evidence that someone else, other than Avery, committed the crime.

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Jerry Buting Michael D. Cicchini Steven Avery

The next president of the Wisconsin State Bar, Paul Swanson, has promised to serve the organization's members in a variety of ways. I take him at his word, and am writing this open letter to suggest a starting point.

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Michael D. Cicchini OLR Paul Swanson Robert Henak State Bar

In Wisconsin, criminal jury instruction 140 defines reasonable doubt for the jury. Strangely, however, after defining reasonable doubt, the instruction concludes by telling jurors that “you are not to search for doubt. You are to search for the truth.”

Tagged with: Critic's Corner juries Michael D. Cicchini

Our nation’s law schools are facing serious troubles, including widespread allegations of false advertising. One California school, for example, is about to stand trial over accusations that it lured students with bogus graduate-employment statistics. Among other law schools facing similar ...

Tagged with: Critic's Corner Michael D. Cicchini

Free speech is under attack — including at our nation’s colleges.

Tagged with: Critic's Corner free speech Michael D. Cicchini