By: Derek Hawkins//February 17, 2016//
WI Court of Appeals – District IV
Case Name: State of Wisconsin v. Robert A. Schoengarth
Case No: 2015AP1834-CR
Officials: BLANCHARD, J.
Focus: OWI – Motion in Limine
The State of Wisconsin has charged Robert Schoengarth with operating while intoxicated—second offense, and operating with a prohibited alcohol concentration—second offense. The State appeals a circuit court order granting Schoengarth’s motion in limine to prevent the State from introducing evidence at trial about two aspects of field sobriety tests that police had Schoengarth perform while on the side of a state highway. The court failed to provide clear reasoning to support its evidentiary decision. For reasons that I now explain, on my independent review of the record, I conclude that the court did not properly exercise its discretion, and accordingly reverse and remand for further proceedings