Home / News / Second federal lawsuit filed over collective bargaining law (UPDATE)

Second federal lawsuit filed over collective bargaining law (UPDATE)

A women wears tape with a protest message over her mouth during a rally outside the state Capitol in Madison shortly after the Wisconsin Supreme Court's ruling on the collective bargaining law on June 14. (AP Photo/Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Tom Lynn)

Associated Press

MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Two unions representing about 2,700 public workers in Madison and Dane County have filed a federal lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of Wisconsin’s new law restricting collective bargaining rights.

The lawsuit, filed Wednesday in U.S. District Court, is the second federal challenge to the law that was pushed by Republican Gov. Scott Walker and passed by the GOP-controlled Legislature earlier this year. The other challenge, filed last month by a broad coalition of unions, is pending.

The law prohibits collective bargaining except over base salary increases no greater than inflation. It took effect June 29 after the state Supreme Court rejected a lawsuit challenging how the bill passed the Legislature.

The law applies to most public workers, including school teachers, but does exempt most police and firefighters, local transit workers and emergency medical service employees.

Exempting some public workers from the law is a violation of equal protection rights under the U.S. Constitution and creates unnecessary conflict, argues the lawsuit filed by two local Madison chapters of the AFL-CIO. The lawsuit, which asks the court to block further implementation of the law, argues it also violates First Amendment rights under the Constitution.

A spokesman for the state Justice Department, which will defend the case, had no immediate comment Thursday.

Bruce Ehlke, the attorney representing those who filed the lawsuit, said he was in no hurry to get a ruling in the case since the labor unions have contracts in place that won’t immediately be affected by the law.

Ehlke had filed a similar lawsuit in state court in March, but withdrew it last month and decided to pursue the issues in federal court instead.

The lawsuit argues that limitations on collective bargaining impair the ability of public sector labor unions to survive and to express the views of those they represent.

The law limits the terms of collective bargaining agreements to one year and prohibits any extensions, requires unions to vote every year to stay in existence, and disallows the automatic withdrawal of union dues from employees’ paychecks.

The lawsuit alleges that those restrictions also impair the ability of public workers to associate with labor unions and to express concerns of mutual interest with their employers.

There is no constitutionally acceptable governmental interest in imposing the restrictions, the lawsuit said.

The other federal lawsuit makes similar arguments. Groups suing in that case include councils of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the Wisconsin State AFL-CIO, the American Federation of Teachers, the Wisconsin Education Association Council, the Wisconsin State Employees Union and the Service Employees International Union-Health Care Wisconsin.

Read more on the collective bargaining law

One comment

  1. You know what this current crowd of GOP liars want is to turn the United Sates into China, where only a few giant corporations run things, they own the factories, the apartments, the grocery stores, the gas stations, the newspaper and magazine publications, the radio stations, the television stations and you pay them and they get all the benefits, and if you do not like it go jump off cliff. Well some Chinese workers seeing that as individuals that they cannot progress have done just that by committing suicide.

    The current crowd of GOP liars want to steal Medicare from the elderly, they want to abolish a woman’s right to choose and have control over her own body, they want to abolish collective bargaining rights for our Unions, and on top of it all they want to blame the poor, the middle class and the public sector workers for a recession that the GOP created (Thanks to the Dullard “W”), while their beloved “Fat cats” continue to pay themselves exorbitant salaries, bonuses, fringe benefits.

    The GOP is like the “Chicken Littles” always saying that the “Sky is Falling”, like the same ones that were the “Chicken Hawks” (“W” Wars), big talk no courage.

    The United States, favors creativity wherever it can be found. We’re apostles of prosperity and defenders of the free exchange of ideas and when more people in more countries are free to rise, to invent, to communicate, to dissent, it’s not the doom of United States leadership, its the triumph of the American way.

    Generations have worked hard and sacrificed much for the country to reach this point (individuals and our Unions that represented our poor, the middle class and public sector workers), and with further hard work and sacrifice (along with our relentless self-doubt) the United States will rise again, we do not tire and we are coming back, no matter what Fox news and their GOP “Chicken Littles” lackies keep saying about our nation. The win in New York was the beginning but the next will be Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Michigan, Ohio, Wisconsin and later the other states of our nation, Never Bet Against the United States, watch out GOP, we are coming for you!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *