By: Derek Hawkins//July 5, 2017//
WI Supreme Court
Case Name: Tracie L. Flug v. Labor and Industry Review Commission, et al.
Case No.: 2017 WI 72
Focus: Workers compensation – Preexisting condition
Tracie L. Flug suffered from two medical conditions——a soft-tissue strain, and a degenerative disc disease. The first was work-related (and has since resolved), the second is not. She underwent surgery in the belief it was necessary to treat her work-related soft-tissue strain. In actuality, it was treating the unrelated degenerative disc disease. The procedure left her with a permanent partial disability. Ms. Flug tells us Wal-Mart (her employer) must compensate her for this permanent partial disability because she believed, in good-faith, that the disability-causing surgery was necessary to treat her work- related condition. We hold today that an employee is not eligible for benefits under Wis. Stat. § 102.42(1m) if the disability-causing treatment was directed at treating something other than the employee’s compensable injury. Because Ms. Flug’s surgery treated her pre-existing condition, not her compensable injury, her claim must be disallowed. We reverse the court of appeals because it should have affirmed the Commission’s decision.
Reversed
Dissent: Roggensack, A.W. Bradley, Abrahamson
Concurring: