By: Derek Hawkins//September 26, 2016//
7th Circuit Court of Appeals
Case Name: Stacy Ernst, et al v. City of Chicago
Case No.: 14-3783; 15-2030
Officials: BAUER, MANION and KANNE , Circuit Judges.
Focus: Title VII
In district court, this Title VII case was split into two parts. The plaintiffs’ disparate-treatment claims went to a jury trial, in which the district court provided an erroneous jury instruction. Their disparate-impact claims were tried in a separate bench trial. This second group of claims turned largely on whether Chicago’s test was based on a statistically validated study of job-related skills. We remand for a new jury trial on the disparate-treatment claims, reverse the bench trial’s verdict on disparate impact because the physical-skills study was neither reliable nor validated under federal law, and affirm the evidentiary rulings below.
Affirmed