By: Derek Hawkins//September 15, 2017//
7th Circuit Court of Appeals
Case Name: Illinois Bible Colleges Association, et al. v. Lindsay K. H., Chair of the Illinois Board of Higher Education
Case No.: 16-1754
Officials: MANION, KANNE, and HAMILTON, Circuit Judges.
Focus: Equal Protection and Establishment Clause Violation
On appeal, the plaintiffs pursue only their federal constitutional claims. They first argue the Illinois regulations violate the Establishment Clause by entangling the government with their religious operations. However, the plaintiffs have not sought certification of approval from the State under the applicable statutes. Therefore, there is no basis to believe that the regulations would infringe on their religious beliefs or practices or would unnecessarily entangle the government in religion. Accordingly, the plaintiffs’ Establishment Clause claim must fail. Likewise, the plaintiffs’ Free Exercise claim fails because the statutes are neutral laws of general application and apply equally to secular and religious institutions.
The plaintiffs’ Equal Protection claim fares no better: While the state statutes exempt older educational institutions from the governing mandates, the law is clear that, when no improper discrimination is involved, the government may include a grandfather clause in legislation without violating the guarantee of Equal Protection. Finally, the student-plaintiff alleges a violation of his right to practice a profession of his choice. But the regulations do not impact that choice. Rather, they merely determine whether he may obtain a degree from specific post-secondary institutions. The district court, therefore, properly dismissed the plaintiffs’ complaint and we affirm.
Affirmed