By: Derek Hawkins//May 16, 2016//
7th Circuit Court of Appeals
Case Name: Jamie Becker v. Zachary Elfreich
Case No.: 15-1363
Officials: FLAUM, MANION, and SYKES, Circuit Judges.
Focus: Excessive Force – Qualified Immunity
Officers excessively violent activities during arrest negate application of qualified immunity.
“When Evansville police attempted to arrest Jamie Becker, Officer Elfreich released his police dog under the belief that Becker was hiding in the house. However, two seconds later, Officer Elfreich discovered Becker had been descending the stairs to surrender with his hands above his head. Nonetheless, Officer Elfreich continued to allow the police dog to bite Becker, while pulling him down three steps and placing his knee on his back and handcuffing him. And Becker suffered serious bodily injury as a result of the dog bite. While it is unclear from the record whether Axel presented a substantial risk of serious risk bodily harm (and thus deadly force), the force was clearly at the more severe end of the force spectrum. A jury could reasonably find such force was excessive. Further, because it was clearly established at the time of Becker’s arrest that no more than minimal force was permissible to arrest a non-resisting, or passively resisting, suspect, Officer Elfreich was not entitled to qualified immunity on this record”
Affirmed and Remanded